One thing I find hard to understand is how it seems like it's all or nothing with most people. Like Q (but not just Q other theories as well) has to be 100% correct or its all completely false. As others have discussed it is such a dynamic battlefield that it would be impossible to predetermined every move that is made. Unless of course you are God or he spoke to you.

Isn't it possible that a bunch of those we have listened to over the last couple years are all partially correct...